Sunday, March 7, 2010

Bonanzle: The Best eBay Alternative We've Seen —

Bonanzle: The Best eBay Alternative We've Seen —

Bonanzle: The Best eBay Alternative We've Seen

By Vangie Beal

July 30, 2008

What do you get when you take the time-consuming, tedious listing process out of auction sites, toss in some cool features, such as on-the-fly image-cropping and live chat, mix it up with a price and description estimator and, really, more features than one should list in an opening sentence?

You get Bonanzle — an eBay alternative that is quite simply, the best I've seen in my four years of reviewing and writing about start-up marketplaces aimed at taking sellers away from eBay.

Editor's Picks

» eBay Alternatives: Fab 15 for Profits Off eBay

» Package Perfect: Offer Free Shipping Without Going Broke

» Time is Money: Batch Edit Photos, Boost Bottom Line

» Review: Using inkFrog Auction Tools for Princely eBay Profits

» Vendio Lifts Veil on eBay Competitor Strategy

Addressing the Needs of Frustrated Sellers

One of the biggest problems that we find on many of the smaller alternative sites, and even on the big sites including eBay itself, is that in their attempt to be so feature-rich, they actually make listing items a chore for experienced sellers and for novices the task can be rather overwhelming.

As a seller, I know I am not alone in my frustration. From having to go through seven or more screens just to select an item category, to doing just as much work to create my own storefront category names (not to mention copying HTML templates from one Web site to another), listing online for the small, average seller is becoming more complex and awkward and you need to invest far too much time in the actual listing process.

During an interview with, the site's founder, Bill Harding, summed up the heart of's philosophy when he said, "Do we really need five or more screens to list a single item?"

Easy Listing with Bonanzle.

(Click for larger image.)

When I clicked the sell button on Bonanzle, this little paragraph-size window popped up, and within that single screen I saw fields for everything I needed to list an item. I knew there had to be more to it, and after taking a good look at the screen, I spotted an "advanced" link. Hitting that brought up a measly two additional lines.

I knew I was looking at an alternative that was very different from the rest of the sites out there.

What Does Bonanzle Have That Others Don't?

To sell an item, you simply click the sell button and fill out a basic single screen listing page; you will need to provide an item title, category, description, price and choose the shipping options from a drop-down menu. It is important to note several key features within the listing screen.

First, when choosing a category, you start typing and suggested categories will appear letting you quickly fill in that part. You can also search Amazon and Yahoo for a description of your item, right from the listing screen, and the system will also display the average selling prices for items matching your own item description. When listing your item, you can save a lot of time by copying the description or by selecting a price shown from Amazon or Yahoo to use for your own Bonanzle products.

Bountiful Ease of Use with Bonanzle Image Cropper.

(Click for larger image.)

From this single listing screen you also add your images. After uploading your product shots, you can use the built in image-cropper to zoom, crop and save images. The image-cropper also serves as yet another Bonanzle time-saver for sellers. Let's say you have 10 items to list. Rather than take 10 photos, upload and edit each one, then add them to your listings, you can simply lay out the items, take one shot, upload it to Bonanzle and use the cropper to show only the relevant part of the image in the listing you are working on. It's one of the easiest image-processing systems I've ever used.

Setting Up Shop and Chatting in Real Time

Bonanzle also has booths, which is their own version of an online store. In a way, it is like the storefronts you find on eBay and other alternatives; however it's a lot less work. You simply provide details on which site format you are most used to (eBay or Craigslist), post your items, set up your seller account and confirm your details. To add additional items later on, you only need to list them on Bonanzle to include them in your booth. No custom category editing required.

Get Cozy in a Bonanzle Booth.

(Click for larger image.)

Another unique aspect of Bonanzle is that it gives the buying and selling community ways to communicate in real-time from within the Web site. When I use Kijiji, for example, it's amazing how much time I have to spend in e-mail. Some prospective buyers want to know the item's history, others want to barter or discuss viewing and pick-up times. On Bonanzle, you can specify pick-up times, and buyers can also use the site's Quick Chat feature to ask sellers these questions in real time, while they are online.

Sellers can keep the chat as an archive for others to view or delete it. You can also opt to receive instant messages (IM) through AIM, Gmail, MSN or other Jabber networks. Bonanzle lets you receive messages from within your booth, and also send messages back from your IM client. It's surprising that no one has considered this style of Quick Chat or seamless IM integration before, and I wouldn't be surprised to see it start surfacing on other sites after seeing how well it works on Bonanzle.

Not a Here Today, Gone Tomorrow Effort

Of course it takes more than a quick listing screen, a built in picture cropper, instant messaging integration, Quick Chat and an online booth to be the kind of marketplace where sellers want to list. But the options and features I've mentioned so far are just the tip of the proverbial iceberg.

To be an alternative that people trust, you also have to show you're in it for the long haul. Sellers are growing weary of the one hit wonders, and want stability and a growing seller and buyer user-base. Part of what makes Bonanzle standout from the other eBay wannabes is that you can tell time, hard work, knowledge and dedication has gone into it. It's not an off-the-shelf package that someone has purchased, edited admin options and then put up on a Web server somewhere.

The Bonanzle platform was designed in-house from the ground up, so not only does the site look very different from other alternative sites, but this is the reason why the tools and features on this site are so radically different.

Harding calls Bonanzle 'the alternative to lookalike Craigslist and eBay alternatives.' I would agree, but the site and its services go well beyond that. The best way to experience Bonanzle is simply to log on and try it. What you will find is that Harding and his team of self-titled "action-minded experts" have managed to offer sellers more features in this one site than any alternative to date, yet keep the entire site and selling process simple, compact and super-easy to use.

Like other eBay alternatives, however, Bonanzle's hurdle is going to be drawing in the many online sellers and buyers that are combing the Web looking for a new marketplace to call home. Currently, the site does show active booths and sellers. On the topic of traffic, Harding said that since the site's "unofficial" beta launch, traffic has steadily increased.

The Cost of Doing Business on Bonanzle

Bonanzle offers free listings to sellers, and for now, while in its unofficial beta stage, you also won't pay any fees when you sell. Harding told that at a later date, final fees will be added to the Web site. Sellers can expect a sliding final sale fee system as follows: no charge for items that sell for under $10, items under $50 will incur a $1 fee, a $100 sale will have a $3 fee, and so on, up to a $10 fee for items selling over $1,000. Harding also said that listing on Bonanzle will always be free.

We'll be checking in on Bonanzle from time to time to see how well this new stellar site performs. Until then, we welcome your feedback and comments on this and any other eBay alternative site you may be using.

Vangie Beal is a seasoned online marketplace seller, frequent contributor to and avid online bargain hunter. She is also managing editor of

Do you have a comment or question about this article or other e-commerce topics in general? Speak out in the E-Commerce Forum. Join the discussion today!


  1. By frustrated ebay-alt seeker.... February 23 2009 6:21 PMPDT
    Hmmm, Bonanzle the best ebay alternative? maybe.

    if it didnt use google checkout, the worst PAYPAL alternative. Want to lose 10's to 100's to 1000's of dollars when google inexplicably cancels your checkout account for a breach in their terms of service and refunds your customers after you've already sent them everything they bought? Look it up, it happens constantly. and google will never explain to you how you breached it. no, this doesnt happen just because you're careless, google tos is so touchy (or shady) that the breaches happen day in and day out, often customers cant find a rule they've broken when reviewing the TOS after. Your account ever be able to be reopened, nor will you be able to make a new one. you'll receive a notice in your email (sometimes!) that your account has been cancelled. that will be the beginning and end of the story for you and your google account.

    Bonanzle seems awesome! i signed up, signed up for google checkout, then researched it. oops! ive cancelled the account, and unfortunately its doubtfull ill be using bonanzle until they offer something else besides paypal. which is why i left ebay in the first

  2. Reply by dh May 17 2009 8:23 PMPDT
    To me Bonanzle is not an auction site so how can it be an alternative to an auction site like eBay ?

    I auction off second hand stuff on eBay (never use buy it now) I can't do that on Bonanzle (see what i'm getting at ) so Bonanzle is not an alternative for me or millions of other ebayers like me who only use the auction format to sell.

    If I was going to sell at fixed price only there are a lot of better and cheaper alternatives to Bonanzle, like your own site and google base.

  3. Reply by wallyh July 30 2009 8:33 AMPDT
    At Bonanzle Paypal and Google Checkout are used for use with shopping cart and BuyItNow. Other methods of payment can also be used. Come visit the Bonanzle forums. Membership is now over 80,000 and gaining 500 new members daily. I'd say it's time for Vangie to revisit Bonanzle and update this article.

  4. Reply by Alilbirdy2 July 30 2009 8:59 AMPDT
    One of the best features of Bonanzle is the fantastic support team. If you have a problem, the members of the support team will respond in person. No canned response.

    This site has continued to grow ever day. If you are wondering where all the buyers and sellers are , just come to and you will find them all there.

  5. Reply by Dr Johnstrous January 20 2010 10:30 PMPDT
    This seems concerning to me...That Google checkout would be nonresponsive and "touchy" re their TOS. Had enough of that crap in the early days of PayPal, until they wized up. If a person isn't hurting kids or other folks with their sales, the bean counters should stick to their beans and not try to dictate morality. IMHO. Hope someone sees this from Google before it bites them in the ***. They're decent folks, I've heard, in most respects.